Always allow a reviewer to request a recheck for a review.
A
Alida Spies
Recently, I've had the situation where two editors edited my review. The one editor deducted points for Oxford commas. The OBC system informed me that there was a discrepancy between the two editors, and I didn't have to take action. I couldn't ask for a recheck. The problem is that the "discrepancy between editors" process does not adjust the editor's score, and the reviewer is unfairly stuck with a reduced score. Please change the system so that a reviewer can always request a recheck.