Don't send editor scorecards to reviewer until two editors have scored review without an objective discrepancy. Have editors sort out objective discrepancies before sending the scorecards to the reviewer. | Voters

Don't send editor scorecards to reviewer until two editors have scored review without an objective discrepancy. Have editors sort out objective discrepancies before sending the scorecards to the reviewer.

planned

Scott Hughes

Many reviewers don't seem to understand that the 'editors' are just their peer reviewers, and then they think OnlineBookClub itself is not properly "training" its editors when editors sent wrong or contradicting information in their scorecards.

April 21, 2025

Alida Spies

Has the process changed, and must every review now have 2 scorecards?

Scott Hughes

marked this post as

planned